Friday, July 25, 2014
This Atlantic article, "Whatever Happened to Dinesh D'Souza?," is an interesting account of how D'Souza went from writing seriously intended (if debatable) conservative books on multiculturalism, education, and politics to peddling s--t about Obama's Kenyan "rage" against America. The thesis is that D'Souza decided that trying to persuade thoughtful people on the other side wasn't worth it (didn't sell books etc.), and just started preaching to the choir. Something that could certainly be said about many smart people today, left and right, who write stuff far below their brainpower.
But here are my favorite sentences in the article:
Yet failing to take on the best arguments of the other side—“to play Notre Dame” in the words of Charlie Peters, editor emeritus of Washington Monthly—carries risks. D’Souza’s subsequent books and films testify to the intellectual pitfalls of ignoring the critics. His demonization of President Obama is a case in point.
They're my favorite, of course, because of the "play Notre Dame" metaphor. (Here's another example of it.) If Protestant/secular quarterbacks/intellectuals are going to take on the best on the other side, they have to mix it up with the fighting Irish. Let's remember, however, how many other Catholic schools have serious Catholic intellectuals (especially in the law schools, of course!), and also serious sports traditions--whether it's St. John's and Villanova basketball, or St. Thomas's potency across the big Division III sports.