Mirror of Justice

A blog dedicated to the development of Catholic legal theory.

Friday, November 15, 2013

Scaraffia and Voce on "Women in the Church"

John Allen's latest column references (and translates, for those of us who don't speak Italian) a recent article on the front page of  L'Osservatore Romano, titled "Women in the Church,"  in which Lucetta Scaraffia  "a widely respected correspondent and columnist who often writes on women's issues", interviewed Maria Voce, president of the international Focolare movement.  Allen writes:


As Scaraffia notes, the Focolare, founded by Italian laywoman Chiara Lubich, have made it a principle of their statutes that the president must be a woman. For that reason, and because the Focolare are among the largest movements, Scaraffia describes Voce as "the most eminent woman in the Catholic world." 


Scaraffia argues that for too long, women were willing to accept a "subaltern" status in the church, but that today, "the situation is changing rapidly." She quotes with approval Voce's line that the church needs not only to appreciate what have been traditionally defined as "female gifts," such as the capacity to form loving relationships, but also that it must "seek out, and listen to, the thinking of women."


Three possible new roles for women emerge in the L'Osseravtore piece:


  • A "not too small" entrance into "organisms of consultation, thought and decisions" in the church. Presumably, though Scaraffia doesn't quite say this out loud, this implies in part more women at decision-making levels in the Vatican.
  • The creation of a consultative body to the pope similar to the Council of Cardinals but composed of both laywomen and men. Such a group, Voce says, "would make me enthusiastic."
  • Allowing movements such as the Focolare to incardinate priests who have been ordained elsewhere. Up to now, Voce reports, permission has been denied -- perhaps, she says, because someone is afraid of putting a priest under the authority of a woman.

"The words of Maria Voce make clear that legitimate requests for true recognition of the feminine presence in the church don't come just from groups of radicals demanding women's ordination, but from authoritative and moderate figures," Scaraffia writes.


"Behind those requests," she adds, "is certainly the majority of women who belong to the church."




Schiltz, Elizabeth | Permalink