« The Implications of Christmas | Main | Thanks to Rick on Anderson, and an Anticipation for the Year Ahead »

December 24, 2009

Anderson on Kirkpatrick on George

A few days ago, Bob noted a recent NYTM profile of our own Robby George ("The Conservative-Christian Big Thinker").  Robby's friend and colleague, Ryan Anderson, discusses the profile in this post.  A bit:

 . . .But the Times profile did misunderstand one pretty important aspect of George’s work.

Throughout the article, George is depicted as having manufactured an entirely new moral and political philosophy, which he now “sells” to the leading Evangelicals and Roman Catholic bishops of America to advance social-conservative causes.

Without a doubt, George and the other so-called “new natural lawyers” are innovative, but their innovations are in the service of reviving and refining what Isaiah Berlin called the central tradition of Western philosophy, the tradition that runs through Aristotle and Aquinas. Rather than manufacturing novel philosophical theories, George and his colleagues see themselves as appropriating and building on the wisdom of the ages to tease out the purposes and meanings of various social practices. In other words, this is philosophically critical conservative thought at its best. . . .

 

Posted by Rick Garnett on December 24, 2009 at 01:40 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515a9a69e20128767d4102970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Anderson on Kirkpatrick on George: